Day 21: Three questions
Read
Notice
- Seven of them go fishing and catch nothing all night, which is where this Gospel found some of them in the first place.
- He has already lit a fire and started cooking before they land, and then asks them to bring fish. He did not need the fish.
- Peter denied him beside a charcoal fire. He is asked three times beside another one. The Greek word for that kind of fire occurs twice in the whole New Testament — John 18:18 and John 21:9 — and John never points it out.
Follow
Jesus asked a third time, “Simon son of John, do you love Me?” Peter was deeply hurt that Jesus had asked him a third time, “Do you love Me?” “Lord, You know all things,” he replied. “You know I love You.” Jesus said to him, “Feed My sheep.John 21:17
The third question, the one that hurt, and the end of the book.
Read together with:
- John 13:38 15 votes
- Mark 14:72 10 votes
- John 16:30 10 votes
- John 15:10 5 votes
Nearest in meaning: Mark 14:72
Two different Greek verbs for love run through this exchange. In 21:15 and 21:16 Jesus asks with one word and Peter answers with this one; in 21:17 Jesus asks with Peter's word instead. Whether John means anything by the swap is genuinely disputed — he trades synonyms elsewhere in the same breath — so read it as a fact about the text rather than a settled point. The fact is that the third time, the question came in the word Peter had been using.
Mark 14:72 is both a cross-reference here and the nearest verse in meaning: the rooster, and Peter going out to weep. Three denials by one fire and three questions by another, and the thread between them was drawn by readers and found again by the embeddings. The commands change each time too — feed the lambs, shepherd the sheep, feed the sheep — and the word for sheep is the one day 10 followed out of the shepherd chapter.
Keep
He was not asked to explain himself, or to apologise, or to promise harder. He was asked the same question three times and given a job each time. What would you do with that?
What it is standing on:
- John 18:18 the first charcoal fire, the one Peter stood warming himself at
- John 13:38 the three denials, foretold
- John 21:15 the first of the three questions, and the first job
That is the Gospel, all twenty-one chapters, and one thread out of each. Every figure you were given along the way — the votes, the scores, the counts — is checked against the corpus before it reaches you. Start a strand of your own, or go back to John 1 and see what you missed.
Every reference, vote count, root count and quoted phrase on this page is checked against the corpus by scripts/check-paths.mjs. All 21 days.